Getting What You Need

Thursday, November 19, 2026

At Ask a Manager, Alison Green posts a collection of replies she received to the question What should the public know about how to deal with the person in your job effectively?

The replies will range from what might seem obvious to the somewhat surprising, and which is which might vary by reader. For example:

Professor working in research. When you reach out with a "cold email," i.e. you want to connect in some way, maybe you're a young scholar looking for collaborations or opportunities:

Keep it short and actionable. Present your research in about two sentences. Be as concrete as you can with what you want from me and ask a specific question, such as, "Can we meet?" "Can I come as a visiting scholar on these dates?" or whatever it is.

It is much less likely to go anywhere if you send a looong loong email and are just basically saying "I exist!" I can't come up with the next step, and I will not read whole paragraphs describing your profile.
I can imagine myself as a young graduate student sending out exactly the type of "networking" spam this guy complains about -- and I can now see myself reacting in exactly the same way to one of those I exist! emails.

Some will be good advice for people dealing with areas in which they don't have a lot of experience.

Others fall under the heading of Don't let social mores get in the way of communicating. To wit:
I work in design. Just tell me what you hate about the thing I made you. Be specific where you can. So many clients don't tell me the truth because they want to be nice, which is a bummer, because I love making people things they love instead of things they halfheartedly accept, and that's tough without honest feedback.

I just got out of a call with a client who said, "It feels overwhelming, that's waaaaay too much text. There's something about the font ... I don't know how to describe it ... I just want something ... softer? If that makes sense? And X is more important than Y, so it should come first, we honestly might not even need Y. Sorry to be so negative!" and I was like, "I love you, actually, we should get married and you can give me specific, actionable feedback forever."
If I were to boil this all down, I might come up with something like Know what you want, and don't be afraid to ask for it in detail. It can be helpful to have lots of examples like this to see why the knowledge and the clarity are both important.

-- CAV


A Mostly Economic Post-Mortem

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Veronique de Rugy's post-mortem of the midterms is both the kind of satisfying tongue-lashing Trump and his party deserve and a good summary of the kind of damage their anti-capitalist policies wreaked. The focus is on economics, but other major policy failures come up.

(I agree with de Rugy on how immigration policy failed politically, even given anti-immigration sentiment. I also agree with her on how Iran is now being used as a distraction, but would add that this was an incredible botching of a winnable war. There was much more de Rugy left out -- Bobby Kennedy's war on our health and Trump's corruption, for example -- but she was writing a column, and not the encyclopedia-length treatise Trump's deficiencies would require.)

First, a bit of the tongue-lashing:

There is no doubt that a lot of bad, big-government policies are in store. But if the prospect of Democrats returning to power is so terrifying, why on earth did Republicans elect a president and vice president as controversial as Donald Trump and J.D. Vance? Why did they support so many policies in clear opposition to the promotion of a free and virtuous society? Did they think a majority of voters would enjoy the result?
This general thing will need to be remembered and brought up over the next couple of years. Every impulsive adjustment of the tariff rates and every nationalization caused me to wonder what the hell the difference would have been had we elected Kamala Harris. Unless the Republicans once again begin to offer an alternative to a command economy, they will keep losing to the people who are at least honest about wanting one.

In two places, de Rugy does a fine job laying out the damage Trump did to the agricultural sector:
Farmers got the worst of it: In 2025, soybean exports to China fell 76 percent, beef by 69 percent, and cotton by 85 percent. In December, the U.S. Department of Agriculture announced a $12 billion bailout for farmers hurt by "unfair market disruptions." It was indeed unfair, but that's because farmers were repeatedly punched in the face by U.S. trade policies that destroyed their export markets. Now the unfairness extends to everyday Americans taxed to compensate the farmers.
And later:
Farmers took a second hit because one-third of the world's traded urea, a product heavily used in agriculture, moves through the Strait of Hormuz. The price of nitrogen fertilizer roughly doubled in a matter of weeks.
So farmers both lost sellers and experienced increases in their business costs due to this impulsive loon's decisions to enter a trade war and a real war. (On the latter, de Rugy is good on results, but weak on the cause: Trump was told he needed to account for Hormuz. He chose to ignore that advice and the gaming out and planning that could have gone with it -- on top of not doing anything to aid regime change in Iran.)

This is a good piece to keep in mind for the next time you hear But, but the Dem Socialists! As de Rugy says, they are to be feared: Where, then is the real alternative?

-- CAV


Will Predicts Dem Frustrations

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

George Will's prediction that "On Jan. 3, Democrats run into reality" provides both comic relief and some cause for optimism for those of us who are alarmed by the prospect of the Democrats becoming Trump's domestic Putin/puppeteer.

Will considers four major "progressive" priorities -- "climate change, campaign finance, Medicare-for-all and racial gerrymandering" -- and argues that none will be smooth sailing for a variety of reasons.

Take socialized medicine, the one I am most concerned about:

Progressives' promises of "Medicare-for-all" elicit rapturous approval from progressive audiences. There is, however, this intractable reality: A large majority of Americans have private health insurance, and a large majority of this majority like their plans. Medicare-for-all must supplant these, which often are untaxed compensation provided by employers.

During World War II, companies competing for scarce labor evaded congressional limits on wages by offering health insurance as untaxed (the IRS agreed to this in 1943) compensation. Medicare-for-all would vitiate many of organized labor's subsequent achievements. That will not happen.
While I don't share Will's confidence, I will concede that he has a point: Pressure group warfare among Democrat constituencies could well buy time from outright socialized medicine. (This, of course, doesn't mean that the Democrats can't still make significant progress in further strangling the medical sector.)

Will's arguments about the other three leftist causes similarly look at the political and institutional obstacles that can frustrate the Democrats as they -- once again -- grossly overestimate their mandate.

-- CAV


Next Up: Dumb Deals With Dems

Monday, November 16, 2026

Predictably, the Democrats who won Congress are mistaking Trump's defeat for a sweeping mandate of their agenda. Unfortunately for the country, getting some control over Trump may well mean having Democrat priorities shoved down our throats this time, since this "Republican" President is in no way a "fiscal conservative" and, next to getting money through bribes and shady "deals," obviously likes praise.

The Democrats know a mark when they see one, and they are already planning to play to Trump's neediness:

Abdul El-Sayed has proposed "TrumpCare," a golden insurance card providing universal healthcare, dangling the president's name on the ambitious Democratic plan.

James Talarico has suggested Donald Trump could become a man of history like Lyndon B. Johnson, who was seen as a master of congressional dealmaking.

And even Hakeem Jeffries, in line to become the House speaker in January, has left the door open to working with the other side of the aisle "wherever and whenever possible" to deliver for the American people.

Some Democrats who swept into power by riding voter backlash to Trump are now pitching ways to collaborate with the president, playing to his vanity and his love of making deals to propel their own agenda. [bold added]
Trump's reputation as a "dealmaker" was thoroughly exposed on the foreign stage throughout the first half of his second term. It should come as no surprise the foreign enemies of American freedom weren't the only ones paying attention. Not only that, the fact that Trump's 40+ nationalizations were a far left idea will not have gone unnoticed, either.

As I have said before, If I were a leftist, I'd be a fan of Trump. He has already won the Democrats a majority: Now he looks set to be their sock puppet.

-- CAV


Four Midterm Things

Friday, November 13, 2026

A Friday Hodgepodge

The historic rebuke of the Trump Presidency led me to discover some interesting things. Here are four of them.

1. Trump is horrible and deserves immediate impeachment and removal from office. Unfortunately, his Vice President is worse in some respects because he is more intelligent and better-organized. I would hope that any effort to remove Trump is paired with one to remove Vance first.

That said, Vice President John C. Calhoun once requested an impeachment inquiry of his own dealings from the House in order to clear his name of an allegation of profiting from a war contract.

Can you imagine anyone in this Administration doing that, either because they know they'd be cleared, or even because they actually care about their reputation among honest people?

2. While I am sure I don't agree with many of Scott Colom's political positions, I am glad he won the Senate seat in Mississippi.

He certainly had one of the best political ads I've ever seen, which I embed below.

Mississippi picked another Senator, instead.

3. Returning to impeachment and removal, I am glad to hear that physician and Senator-elect Annie Andrews (D-SC) has said that "I believe we need to impeach and remove RFK Jr."

Unfortunately, she is on the socialized medicine bandwagon, but getting rid of Kennedy would be a good first step towards addressing a serious health hazard millions of Americans now face in the person of that malevolent crackpot.

4. As I noted earlier in the week, Elon Musk's poor return on his huge political expenditures in Texas provides a welcome counterexample to the idea that "the rich" can "buy" elections.

-- CAV


A Good Job Hunt Debunking

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Regulars will know that I love a good debunking, especially if it's of something that "everyone knows."

If you can't get the world to stop babbling nonsense to you, the next best thing is to have a solid understanding of why said nonsense is wrong, and, as a bonus, be confident in your ability to shoot down the worst offenders.

In the realm of job hunting, one of these eight glasses of water a day is Bust a hump trying to find and apply to jobs within an hour of their being posted.

This has always struck me as ridiculous and, although I have always ignored this "advice," it was fun hearing an experienced hiring manager explain what's wrong with it:

Most hiring managers look at applications either in batches or all at once at the end of the application period. They're not waiting breathlessly by their application portal looking at candidates as they come in over the first hour or two after a job is posted. (Hell, many hiring managers don't even know exactly when a job is posted, just that it will be "today" or "sometime this week").

Moreover, anyone who has been hiring for a while knows that, to the extent that you can find patterns, the very earliest applications are rarely the strongest matches because they're mostly people who are just applying to everything they see, and the strongest candidates tend to come later because they're being more selective. (This is just a general pattern; obviously there are exceptions.)

Plus, there's no way you can customize your application if you're racing to get it in within an hour of the job posting.
On top of the fun and reassurance of the above, Alison Green does address the parts of this advice that are true, namely that: (1) There are some jobs for which this is true, but they are generally the kinds of jobs most people don't want; and (2) It is advantageous to apply to a position you want soon after it is posted, but with soon meaning within a couple of weeks, not immediately.

-- CAV


Electoral College, RIP?

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

As I speculated here in May, yet another midterm casualty of Trump's corruption and lawlessness may turn out to be the Electoral College.

In that update on the progress of a leftist effort to work around the Electoral College, I noted:

As of now, that total [of electoral votes in state signatories to the "National Popular Vote" compact] is 222, and, as Vox points out, there is a real chance that this year's midterms, fueled by widespread discontent with Donald Trump and his congressional Republican lapdogs, could cause the balance to tip over the decisive 270 electoral votes required to make the compact binding.
At RealClear Politics, political scientist James Sieja indicates that the results of the midterms have set the stage for that to happen in any number of ways:
Until the wee hours of Wednesday morning, the NPVC was stuck at 222 Electoral College votes.

However, with Democrats gaining lawmaking authority – i.e., control of both houses of the state legislature and governorship – in Arizona, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and Nevada, the NPVC has a clear shot of controlling the outcome of the 2028 election.

If the five newly Democrat-controlled states pass compact legislation, the NPVC will reach 283 Electoral College votes. Any one of Arizona, Wisconsin, or Nevada could not pass NPVC legislation, and the compact will still go into effect.
The Sieja piece, as well as my past posts on this endeavor bring up the downsides to the realization of this effort, which presumably would need to pass muster before the Supreme Court to take effect.

-- CAV