Getting What You Need
Thursday, November 19, 2026
At Ask a Manager, Alison Green posts a collection of replies she received to the question What should the public know about how to deal with the person in your job effectively?
The replies will range from what might seem obvious to the somewhat surprising, and which is which might vary by reader. For example:
Professor working in research. When you reach out with a "cold email," i.e. you want to connect in some way, maybe you're a young scholar looking for collaborations or opportunities:I can imagine myself as a young graduate student sending out exactly the type of "networking" spam this guy complains about -- and I can now see myself reacting in exactly the same way to one of those I exist! emails.
Keep it short and actionable. Present your research in about two sentences. Be as concrete as you can with what you want from me and ask a specific question, such as, "Can we meet?" "Can I come as a visiting scholar on these dates?" or whatever it is.
It is much less likely to go anywhere if you send a looong loong email and are just basically saying "I exist!" I can't come up with the next step, and I will not read whole paragraphs describing your profile.
Some will be good advice for people dealing with areas in which they don't have a lot of experience.
Others fall under the heading of Don't let social mores get in the way of communicating. To wit:
I work in design. Just tell me what you hate about the thing I made you. Be specific where you can. So many clients don't tell me the truth because they want to be nice, which is a bummer, because I love making people things they love instead of things they halfheartedly accept, and that's tough without honest feedback.If I were to boil this all down, I might come up with something like Know what you want, and don't be afraid to ask for it in detail. It can be helpful to have lots of examples like this to see why the knowledge and the clarity are both important.
I just got out of a call with a client who said, "It feels overwhelming, that's waaaaay too much text. There's something about the font ... I don't know how to describe it ... I just want something ... softer? If that makes sense? And X is more important than Y, so it should come first, we honestly might not even need Y. Sorry to be so negative!" and I was like, "I love you, actually, we should get married and you can give me specific, actionable feedback forever."
-- CAV