Groundhog Day, and They Don't Even Know It
Wednesday, June 24, 2026
John Stossel's report on the latest attempt by central planners to "fix" contract work contains the following incredible passage:
The Democratic Socialists said they had a solution. Seattle's city council imposed a $26 delivery driver minimum wage.The last line is not the good news we might momentarily out of hope imagine it to be: All these fools could come up with to explain the devastation they wrought was that they'd picked the wrong number.
What could go wrong?
Two years later, we know the answer: Gig workers make no more money, but prices went up.
Apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats added a $5 fee for consumers "to help cover the costs of these ... regulations."
Now Seattle residents complain about prices. "I ordered a $12 sandwich ... $12 grew to $32!" complains one in my new video. "I just deleted the app."
"[Work] has become slow because of the new law," an app driver complains. DoorDash says it got 1.7 million fewer Seattle orders in 2024.
This is what happens when politicians dictate wages.
...
Former Seattle City Council President Sara Nelson admits that the politicians made a mistake: "We created a problem and it's our responsibility to fix it." [bold added]
That passage reminds me of the following from Leonard Peikoff's lecture, "My Thirty Years With Ayn Rand:"
Ayn Rand started thinking in terms of principles, she told me once, at the age of twelve. To her, it was a normal part of the process of growing up, and she never dropped the method thereafter. Nor, I believe, did she ever entirely comprehend the fact that the approach which was second nature to her was not practiced by other people. Much of the time, she was baffled by or indignant at the people she was doomed to talk to, people like the man we heard about in the early 1950s, who was calling for the nationalization of the steel industry. The man was told by an Objectivist why government seizure of the steel industry was immoral and impractical, and he was impressed by the argument. His comeback was: "Okay, I see that. But what about the coal industry?" (Voice of Reason, p. 341-342)Today, our politicians seem to be a choice of outright criminals -- or people like that man.
Forget about rightly pointing out that two people have the inalienable right to contract bewteen themselves how much one will pay the other for an agreed-upon service. These people can't even apply relatively simple priciples like supply and demand to questions such as What happens to a market when a price is set arbitrarily?
And these are the politicians who are at least willing to admit a mistake.
We are in trouble.
-- CAV
2 comments:
Happy 4th Gus!!:
You are right!! We are in trouble. This post got me thinking about my own situation at the moment. I am working as a remote independent contractor for a company that is in Florida. The client is a world renowned accountancy software firm. The pay is atrociously low, but it works for me at the moment. I noticed the company will not hire independent contractors in CA, NM, and WA. And its precisely due to those bad laws that outlaw gig work. Yet, its the residents who are at fault for voting for these people.
I was browsing the Ask the Manager site when someone asked if they should lie about their residency due to the fact that the remote job they applied for will not hire anyone from California. Allison Greene rightly told poster that it was illegal and morally wrong. I wonder if that poster contacted her state legislatures to complain about the law that is making it impossible for her to find work? Just like you pointed out Gus, it is Groundhog Day, and no one realizes it. I get a headache thinking about it!!
Bookish Babe
BB,
Happy belated Independence Day! I was on a blogging break, but am back as of now.
I am pretty sure I see the moral aspect differently than Green. I see the lying there as akin to the kind of lie one ought to tell to an evil man who will use the information to commit a crime -- assuming the lie id not self-sacrificial.
The relevant context is the illegality: Circumventing such laws is not immoral, but setting oneself up for difficulties with the law is, outside of trying to start a test case.
Gus
Post a Comment