Will Predicts Dem Frustrations

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

George Will's prediction that "On Jan. 3, Democrats run into reality" provides both comic relief and some cause for optimism for those of us who are alarmed by the prospect of the Democrats becoming Trump's domestic Putin/puppeteer.

Will considers four major "progressive" priorities -- "climate change, campaign finance, Medicare-for-all and racial gerrymandering" -- and argues that none will be smooth sailing for a variety of reasons.

Take socialized medicine, the one I am most concerned about:

Progressives' promises of "Medicare-for-all" elicit rapturous approval from progressive audiences. There is, however, this intractable reality: A large majority of Americans have private health insurance, and a large majority of this majority like their plans. Medicare-for-all must supplant these, which often are untaxed compensation provided by employers.

During World War II, companies competing for scarce labor evaded congressional limits on wages by offering health insurance as untaxed (the IRS agreed to this in 1943) compensation. Medicare-for-all would vitiate many of organized labor's subsequent achievements. That will not happen.
While I don't share Will's confidence, I will concede that he has a point: Pressure group warfare among Democrat constituencies could well buy time from outright socialized medicine. (This, of course, doesn't mean that the Democrats can't still make significant progress in further strangling the medical sector.)

Will's arguments about the other three leftist causes similarly look at the political and institutional obstacles that can frustrate the Democrats as they -- once again -- grossly overestimate their mandate.

-- CAV

No comments: