A Mostly Economic Post-Mortem
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Veronique de Rugy's post-mortem of the midterms is both the kind of satisfying tongue-lashing Trump and his party deserve and a good summary of the kind of damage their anti-capitalist policies wreaked. The focus is on economics, but other major policy failures come up.
(I agree with de Rugy on how immigration policy failed politically, even given anti-immigration sentiment. I also agree with her on how Iran is now being used as a distraction, but would add that this was an incredible botching of a winnable war. There was much more de Rugy left out -- Bobby Kennedy's war on our health and Trump's corruption, for example -- but she was writing a column, and not the encyclopedia-length treatise Trump's deficiencies would require.)
First, a bit of the tongue-lashing:
There is no doubt that a lot of bad, big-government policies are in store. But if the prospect of Democrats returning to power is so terrifying, why on earth did Republicans elect a president and vice president as controversial as Donald Trump and J.D. Vance? Why did they support so many policies in clear opposition to the promotion of a free and virtuous society? Did they think a majority of voters would enjoy the result?This general thing will need to be remembered and brought up over the next couple of years. Every impulsive adjustment of the tariff rates and every nationalization caused me to wonder what the hell the difference would have been had we elected Kamala Harris. Unless the Republicans once again begin to offer an alternative to a command economy, they will keep losing to the people who are at least honest about wanting one.
In two places, de Rugy does a fine job laying out the damage Trump did to the agricultural sector:
Farmers got the worst of it: In 2025, soybean exports to China fell 76 percent, beef by 69 percent, and cotton by 85 percent. In December, the U.S. Department of Agriculture announced a $12 billion bailout for farmers hurt by "unfair market disruptions." It was indeed unfair, but that's because farmers were repeatedly punched in the face by U.S. trade policies that destroyed their export markets. Now the unfairness extends to everyday Americans taxed to compensate the farmers.And later:
Farmers took a second hit because one-third of the world's traded urea, a product heavily used in agriculture, moves through the Strait of Hormuz. The price of nitrogen fertilizer roughly doubled in a matter of weeks.So farmers both lost sellers and experienced increases in their business costs due to this impulsive loon's decisions to enter a trade war and a real war. (On the latter, de Rugy is good on results, but weak on the cause: Trump was told he needed to account for Hormuz. He chose to ignore that advice and the gaming out and planning that could have gone with it -- on top of not doing anything to aid regime change in Iran.)
This is a good piece to keep in mind for the next time you hear But, but the Dem Socialists! As de Rugy says, they are to be feared: Where, then is the real alternative?
-- CAV
2 comments:
As I said when Trump was elected the first time, the whole issue is that both parties have given more and more power to the President. Trump is going much further than anyone in the past, but frankly the same could be said about every president before him. The whole point of the US form of government was to have checks and balances to prevent exactly what we are seeing.
A single man ended 80 years of American hegemony and destroyed a system that had generally maintained peace since WWII (with, admittedly, some hiccups). The system survived the end of the USSR, but didn't survive 6 years of Trump. This is far, far too much power for any one person to wield.
The lesson both the Democrats and we the people need to take from this is that the office of the president needs to be curtailed. It will always be a powerful office by its nature, but we can establish constraints to limit the ability of one man to unilaterally disrupt trade, start wars, and alienate entire blocs of allies. As an added bonus, this should re-establish some of the freedom we've given up over the years.
My guess is that what we'll see is Democrats using the powers Trump as assumed as president when next they take office, continuing the ratchetting down of our freedoms.
Yes. We fail to back off the so-called imperial Presidency at our peril.
Post a Comment